Some people make the mistake of thinking that their credit card miles are free. That’s a terrible error. Miles you earn from credit card spend is not free. The welcome bonus might be, but anything else is not.
In most circumstances, this is because you earn miles and points by foregoing something else – cashback. Most premium credit cards earn you one mile per dollar, whether it’s Aeroplan, Membership Rewards, or any currency. It’s not bad, but you need to compare it to the MBNA Rewards World Elite MasterCard. This is one of the best cash back cards available. It earns two rewards points per dollar, along with 10,000 bonus points after completing your first purchase. Each 10,000 points can be redeemed for $100, so it effectively is a 2% return.
This means, for each dollar you spend, you must earn the equivalent of 2.0 Canadian cents or 1.55 US cents in value. If you earn less than that, then you should switch your credit card. With bonus categories, the opportunity cost is even more apparent. The American Express Cobalt Card earns 5 points for every $1 spent on groceries and dining, equivalent to a 5.0 cent return. Any time you use another card, you pay more for your points than you might think.
I value Aeroplan Miles at 1.6 cents USD, so it only makes marginally more sense to use an Aeroplan card instead of a cashback card. However, if you don’t value Aeroplan miles as highly as I do, then it makes even more sense to use an alternative card. In any case, that’s why I don’t use an Aeroplan co-branded card for most transactions. My go-to card is the SPG American Express for everyday purchases. It earns 1 Starpoint per dollar, which I value at 2.15 cents. For non-AMEX spend, I use the MBNA Alaska Airlines World Elite MasterCard. Each Alaska mile is worth 1.8-1.9 cents.
It’s difficult to quantify how much a mile is worth – so technically this is all theoretical. But for most households that spend mid-five figures on their credit cards, you should think about this whenever you pay for something with a credit card.